Affiliate links sometimes earn us commission. It doesn't cost you anything. Ever.

Stewart And Hamilton Mattress Review

We picked the 10 best mattresses using real tests & research to help you live a happier, healthier life!

Editor's Note

• Stewart and Hamilton is a low-cost innerspring hybrid pillow-top sold at American Freight and other retailers.
• They have a 5-year warranty (average is 10-15 years), and poor construction & material quality (users complain about longevity).
• Buy a good mattress if you want that innerspring 'feel'. We recommend Saatva Classic (the #1 Stewart Hamilton alternative). They make high-end, super-comfortable innerspring hybrids. Customer service is great (they're arguably the best in the industry) & they have friendly policies. Check Saatva Classic out, here.

Real Reviews For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Here are several relevant and useful comments from buyers considering or have already purchased Stewart And Hamilton Mattress.

• User 1: "Looks can be deceiving!! Bought this because it was advertised as soft and cooling! Neither of which I got with this mattress. It immediately dipped down and lost its shape on my husbands and my side and we are pretty small people. Hubby only weighs 135-140 I weight a bit more but I rotated the mattress like I was supposed to and everything but it hurts us so bad. We wake up everyday in so much pain. So we are searching for a new mattress now!!"

• User 2: "The coils dig into my side so i doubled up two comforters to make it bareable but going to have to add a third. the coils feel very loose and i get a touch of vertigo when i lay down on it.The mattress feels like i need to conform to it not it conforming to me."

• User 3: "I bought mine not even 2 Mo the ago. It's warped. And I only weigh 130lbs so Weight isn't the problem. Now I'm stuck with it, got it at discount price because the store here in Waukesha was closing. Not to mention I did $65 delivery fee and 1 guy brought it tied to the top of his Saturn. So much for a good night's rest."

Real Reviews For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Here are several relevant and useful comments from buyers considering or have already purchased Stewart And Hamilton Mattress.

• User 1: "Looks can be deceiving!! Bought this because it was advertised as soft and cooling! Neither of which I got with this mattress. It immediately dipped down and lost its shape on my husbands and my side and we are pretty small people. Hubby only weighs 135-140 I weight a bit more but I rotated the mattress like I was supposed to and everything but it hurts us so bad. We wake up everyday in so much pain. So we are searching for a new mattress now!!"

• User 2: "The coils dig into my side so i doubled up two comforters to make it bareable but going to have to add a third. the coils feel very loose and i get a touch of vertigo when i lay down on it.The mattress feels like i need to conform to it not it conforming to me."

• User 3: "I bought mine not even 2 Mo the ago. It's warped. And I only weigh 130lbs so Weight isn't the problem. Now I'm stuck with it, got it at discount price because the store here in Waukesha was closing. Not to mention I did $65 delivery fee and 1 guy brought it tied to the top of his Saturn. So much for a good night's rest."

Why Pocket Coils?

COMFORT OVERVIEW
Comfort, feel and overall firmness for Stewart And Hamilton mattress is extremely subjective.

Firmness isn't the only factor to consider when you're mattress shopping.

Choosing the right bed starts with figuring out how your body responds to lying at different angles.

It's important to understand how a mattress relieves pain and distributes pressure on your sensitive points (neck, shoulder, upper back, lower back, arms, hips, legs), as well as how it feels for couples and sex.

COMFORT SUMMARY
Firmness is very subjective and greatly differs between two people. What's firm for you might be extremely soft for someone else.

Be cautious about reviews that make definitive claims about how you'll feel sleeping on a mattress.

Stewart & Hamilton offers plush and medium firm models.

It'll probably support most positions for a few months (if that). What happens beyond that is anyone's guess (because it's relatively low quality).

After a few years, don't expect its firmness to retain its shape.

EDGE SUPPORT
• Edge support is likely not good. Low retail price means materials they use to bolster their edges is either nonexistent or poor quality. We doubt the edges last more than 1-3 years with consistent use.
• Online specs give almost no granular detail on steps they take to bolster their edge support outside '365' foam encasement.

Note: If a mattress uses low-quality materials, it might feel supportive at first, but break down quickly.

Inadequate edge support means less sleep surface (which is not desirable, especially if you sleep with a partner).

SIDE SLEEPERS
• Your shoulders, hips and torso must evenly distribute support if you sleep on your side. Otherwise concentrated pressure causes long term nerve and pain-related issues.
• Look for Stewart and Hamilton's plush model - this is ideal for side sleeping. Their softer version has a great balance of cushioned firmness and contouring support (essential for side sleeping).

BACK/STOMACH SLEEPERS
• When you sleep on your back & stomach, your biggest concern should be finding a mattress that keeps your hips from sinking too far in. This knocks your spine out of alignment.
• Stewart and Hamilton mattresses provide adequate support while still feeling contouring to your sensitive areas. Overall, this makes it a decent choice for back and stomach sleepers.

Side Sleeping On Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Back & Stomach Sleeping On Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Construction & Design For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Spring vs. Foam vs. Latex - Which Is Best For Me?

Here are a few facts about Stewart And Hamilton mattress construction:

• Type - hybrid innerspring
• Design - pillow-top and euro-top
• Bed in a Box? - yes
• Height - 11-13" (model dependant)
• Weight (Queen) - unknown weight

Their primary layers include:

• Cover - stretch knit fabric
• Comfort Layer - foam
• Transition Layer - foam
• Support Layer - pocketed coils
• Other Notable Specs - none

Note: A taller and heavier mattress typically (but not always) indicate better quality.

Height For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Edge support for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Support & Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

There are several noteworthy considerations with the Stewart And Hamilton return policy:

• difficult to find any information on their return policy. Some users report 30 and 120-days depending on which retailer they purchased from.

Exchange Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Warranty Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

WARRANTY INFO

• has a 10 year limited warranty with a lot of fine print. We strongly do not recommend brands that have warranties like this.

EXCHANGE INFO

• likely has no exchange policy. They don't have a dedicated website, so any retailer selling this mattress probably has a poor (or non-existent) exchange policy in place.

Look for warranties that have at least a 15-year period with no unreasonable limitations or transporation fees.

Also, find a brand with an exchange policy that doesn't have exorbitant fees in case you need to switch firmnesses.

How much does Stewart And Hamilton Mattress cost?

The Stewart And Hamilton costs $380 for their Queen size.

Keep in mind their prices change frequently during big holiday and sales periods.

Customer service for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Is Stewart And Hamilton Mattress An Eco-Friendly & Organic Brand?

Where Can I Buy Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

You can buy Stewart And Hamilton at the following locations:

• by several retailers, including American Freight and Wayfair

Where can I buy Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

You can buy Stewart And Hamilton at the following locations:

• by several retailers, including American Freight and Wayfair

Shipping Info for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Final verdict for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return & Exchange Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

There are several noteworthy considerations with the Stewart And Hamilton return policy:

• difficult to find any information on their return policy. Some users report 30 and 120-days depending on which retailer they purchased from.

Which mattress Materials Should I look For?

Warranty & Exchange Policy for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

WARRANTY INFO

• has a 10 year limited warranty with a lot of fine print. We strongly do not recommend brands that have warranties like this.

EXCHANGE INFO

• likely has no exchange policy. They don't have a dedicated website, so any retailer selling this mattress probably has a poor (or non-existent) exchange policy in place.

Look for warranties that have at least a 15-year period with no unreasonable limitations or transporation fees.

Also, find a brand with an exchange policy that doesn't have exorbitant fees in case you need to switch firmnesses.

Online vs. In-Store

Warranty & Exchange Policy for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

WARRANTY INFO

• has a 10 year limited warranty with a lot of fine print. We strongly do not recommend brands that have warranties like this.

EXCHANGE INFO

• likely has no exchange policy. They don't have a dedicated website, so any retailer selling this mattress probably has a poor (or non-existent) exchange policy in place.

Look for warranties that have at least a 15-year period with no unreasonable limitations or transporation fees.

Also, find a brand with an exchange policy that doesn't have exorbitant fees in case you need to switch firmnesses.

3 Best Pocket Coil Mattresses

The Stewart And Hamilton costs $380 for their Queen size.

Keep in mind their prices change frequently during big holiday and sales periods.

Buy Or Skip Stewart And Hamilton Mattress?

Are There Good Alternatives To Stewart And Hamilton Mattress?

Alternatives To Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Absolutely, yes. There are incredible alternatives to Stewart And Hamilton's mattress. Don't underestimate how confusing it is to find your ideal mattress.

Depending on your preferences, here are our 3 top alternatives:

1. The Saatva Classic is a durable innerspring hybrid that's very comfortable. They're great for people who like a little bounce but want support and value.

2. Loom & Leaf - We love Loom & Leaf because it has zero motion transfer and excellent pressure relief.

3. Zenhaven - 100% organic and natural Talalay latex. It's the best mattress money can buy. You should check out this mattress if you need a bed that has some bounce, but still fully envelops and supports your pressure points.

Our ultimate goal is very simple. Identify your perfect mattress and steer you in the right direction!

Expert Summary

• Stewart and Hamilton is a low-cost innerspring hybrid pillow-top sold at American Freight and other retailers.
• They have a 5-year warranty (average is 10-15 years), and poor construction & material quality (users complain about longevity).
• Buy a good mattress if you want that innerspring 'feel'. We recommend Saatva Classic (the #1 Stewart Hamilton alternative). They make high-end, super-comfortable innerspring hybrids. Customer service is great (they're arguably the best in the industry) & they have friendly policies. Check Saatva Classic out, here.

See Exclusive Black Friday Deal →

#1 Rated: Saatva Classic

Saatva is our #1 best mattress for 2022! 50k+ 5-star reviews.

FREE white-glove delivery

51,927 

 reviews

Claim My Deal →

Editor's Note

• Stewart and Hamilton is a low-cost innerspring hybrid pillow-top sold at American Freight and other retailers.
• They have a 5-year warranty (average is 10-15 years), and poor construction & material quality (users complain about longevity).
• Buy a good mattress if you want that innerspring 'feel'. We recommend Saatva Classic (the #1 Stewart Hamilton alternative). They make high-end, super-comfortable innerspring hybrids. Customer service is great (they're arguably the best in the industry) & they have friendly policies. Check Saatva Classic out, here.

Summary

Stewart and Hamilton is a cheap innerspring hybrid sold at various retailers. They have a short 5-year warranty with questionable material quality.

Our #1 alternative is Saatva Classic. Saatva offers a real luxury experience that you'd expect from the best hotels in the world.

You can check them out, here.

Consider Stewart And Hamilton Mattress if

Pros

Pros

  • Adequate for barely-used guest rooms

Skip Stewart And Hamilton Mattress if

Cons

Cons

  • Cheap build quality
  • Questionable policies & customer experience
  • Far better alternatives (like Saatva Classic)

Real Reviews For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Here are several relevant and useful comments from buyers considering or have already purchased Stewart And Hamilton Mattress.

• User 1: "Looks can be deceiving!! Bought this because it was advertised as soft and cooling! Neither of which I got with this mattress. It immediately dipped down and lost its shape on my husbands and my side and we are pretty small people. Hubby only weighs 135-140 I weight a bit more but I rotated the mattress like I was supposed to and everything but it hurts us so bad. We wake up everyday in so much pain. So we are searching for a new mattress now!!"

• User 2: "The coils dig into my side so i doubled up two comforters to make it bareable but going to have to add a third. the coils feel very loose and i get a touch of vertigo when i lay down on it.The mattress feels like i need to conform to it not it conforming to me."

• User 3: "I bought mine not even 2 Mo the ago. It's warped. And I only weigh 130lbs so Weight isn't the problem. Now I'm stuck with it, got it at discount price because the store here in Waukesha was closing. Not to mention I did $65 delivery fee and 1 guy brought it tied to the top of his Saturn. So much for a good night's rest."

Real Reviews For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Here are several relevant and useful comments from buyers considering or have already purchased Stewart And Hamilton Mattress.

• User 1: "Looks can be deceiving!! Bought this because it was advertised as soft and cooling! Neither of which I got with this mattress. It immediately dipped down and lost its shape on my husbands and my side and we are pretty small people. Hubby only weighs 135-140 I weight a bit more but I rotated the mattress like I was supposed to and everything but it hurts us so bad. We wake up everyday in so much pain. So we are searching for a new mattress now!!"

• User 2: "The coils dig into my side so i doubled up two comforters to make it bareable but going to have to add a third. the coils feel very loose and i get a touch of vertigo when i lay down on it.The mattress feels like i need to conform to it not it conforming to me."

• User 3: "I bought mine not even 2 Mo the ago. It's warped. And I only weigh 130lbs so Weight isn't the problem. Now I'm stuck with it, got it at discount price because the store here in Waukesha was closing. Not to mention I did $65 delivery fee and 1 guy brought it tied to the top of his Saturn. So much for a good night's rest."

Comfort, Feel & Firmness For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

COMFORT OVERVIEW
Comfort, feel and overall firmness for Stewart And Hamilton mattress is extremely subjective.

Firmness isn't the only factor to consider when you're mattress shopping.

Choosing the right bed starts with figuring out how your body responds to lying at different angles.

It's important to understand how a mattress relieves pain and distributes pressure on your sensitive points (neck, shoulder, upper back, lower back, arms, hips, legs), as well as how it feels for couples and sex.

COMFORT SUMMARY
Firmness is very subjective and greatly differs between two people. What's firm for you might be extremely soft for someone else.

Be cautious about reviews that make definitive claims about how you'll feel sleeping on a mattress.

Stewart & Hamilton offers plush and medium firm models.

It'll probably support most positions for a few months (if that). What happens beyond that is anyone's guess (because it's relatively low quality).

After a few years, don't expect its firmness to retain its shape.

EDGE SUPPORT
• Edge support is likely not good. Low retail price means materials they use to bolster their edges is either nonexistent or poor quality. We doubt the edges last more than 1-3 years with consistent use.
• Online specs give almost no granular detail on steps they take to bolster their edge support outside '365' foam encasement.

Note: If a mattress uses low-quality materials, it might feel supportive at first, but break down quickly.

Inadequate edge support means less sleep surface (which is not desirable, especially if you sleep with a partner).

SIDE SLEEPERS
• Your shoulders, hips and torso must evenly distribute support if you sleep on your side. Otherwise concentrated pressure causes long term nerve and pain-related issues.
• Look for Stewart and Hamilton's plush model - this is ideal for side sleeping. Their softer version has a great balance of cushioned firmness and contouring support (essential for side sleeping).

BACK/STOMACH SLEEPERS
• When you sleep on your back & stomach, your biggest concern should be finding a mattress that keeps your hips from sinking too far in. This knocks your spine out of alignment.
• Stewart and Hamilton mattresses provide adequate support while still feeling contouring to your sensitive areas. Overall, this makes it a decent choice for back and stomach sleepers.

Side Sleeping On Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Back & Stomach Sleeping On Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Construction & Design For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Construction & Materials For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Here are a few facts about Stewart And Hamilton mattress construction:

• Type - hybrid innerspring
• Design - pillow-top and euro-top
• Bed in a Box? - yes
• Height - 11-13" (model dependant)
• Weight (Queen) - unknown weight

Their primary layers include:

• Cover - stretch knit fabric
• Comfort Layer - foam
• Transition Layer - foam
• Support Layer - pocketed coils
• Other Notable Specs - none

Note: A taller and heavier mattress typically (but not always) indicate better quality.

Height For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Edge support for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Support & Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Motion Isolation For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

There are several noteworthy considerations with the Stewart And Hamilton return policy:

• difficult to find any information on their return policy. Some users report 30 and 120-days depending on which retailer they purchased from.

Exchange Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Warranty Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

WARRANTY INFO

• has a 10 year limited warranty with a lot of fine print. We strongly do not recommend brands that have warranties like this.

EXCHANGE INFO

• likely has no exchange policy. They don't have a dedicated website, so any retailer selling this mattress probably has a poor (or non-existent) exchange policy in place.

Look for warranties that have at least a 15-year period with no unreasonable limitations or transporation fees.

Also, find a brand with an exchange policy that doesn't have exorbitant fees in case you need to switch firmnesses.

How much does Stewart And Hamilton Mattress cost?

The Stewart And Hamilton costs $380 for their Queen size.

Keep in mind their prices change frequently during big holiday and sales periods.

Customer service for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Is Stewart And Hamilton Mattress An Eco-Friendly & Organic Brand?

Where Can I Buy Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

You can buy Stewart And Hamilton at the following locations:

• by several retailers, including American Freight and Wayfair

Where can I buy Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

You can buy Stewart And Hamilton at the following locations:

• by several retailers, including American Freight and Wayfair

Shipping Info for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Final verdict for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return & Exchange Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Return Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

There are several noteworthy considerations with the Stewart And Hamilton return policy:

• difficult to find any information on their return policy. Some users report 30 and 120-days depending on which retailer they purchased from.

Warranty Policy For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Warranty & Exchange Policy for Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

WARRANTY INFO

• has a 10 year limited warranty with a lot of fine print. We strongly do not recommend brands that have warranties like this.

EXCHANGE INFO

• likely has no exchange policy. They don't have a dedicated website, so any retailer selling this mattress probably has a poor (or non-existent) exchange policy in place.

Look for warranties that have at least a 15-year period with no unreasonable limitations or transporation fees.

Also, find a brand with an exchange policy that doesn't have exorbitant fees in case you need to switch firmnesses.

Pricing For Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

The Stewart And Hamilton costs $380 for their Queen size.

Keep in mind their prices change frequently during big holiday and sales periods.

Buy Or Skip Stewart And Hamilton Mattress?

Are There Good Alternatives To Stewart And Hamilton Mattress?

Alternatives To Stewart And Hamilton Mattress

Absolutely, yes. There are incredible alternatives to Stewart And Hamilton's mattress. Don't underestimate how confusing it is to find your ideal mattress.

Depending on your preferences, here are our 3 top alternatives:

1. The Saatva Classic is a durable innerspring hybrid that's very comfortable. They're great for people who like a little bounce but want support and value.

2. Loom & Leaf - We love Loom & Leaf because it has zero motion transfer and excellent pressure relief.

3. Zenhaven - 100% organic and natural Talalay latex. It's the best mattress money can buy. You should check out this mattress if you need a bed that has some bounce, but still fully envelops and supports your pressure points.

Our ultimate goal is very simple. Identify your perfect mattress and steer you in the right direction!

See Exclusive Black Friday Deal →

#1 Rated: Saatva Classic

Saatva is our #1 best mattress for 2022! 50k+ 5-star reviews.

FREE white-glove delivery

51,927 

 reviews

Claim My Deal →
See Exclusive Black Friday Deal →
Claim My Deal →